NSLU2-Linux
view · edit · print · history

HowTo.CompareUPnP History

Hide minor edits - Show changes to markup

March 10, 2011, at 10:47 AM by OddballHero -- Clean up links.
Changed line 191 from:

Latest version of Twonky 5.01 is unable to handle my collection of >20000 songs, it runs out of memory. So I'm now in the process of trying all of the available media servers to find a replacement that is actively supported. Have tried Ushare, FireFly? and MediaTomb, Ushare is the only one so far to cope with the number of songs. Ushare has also streamed DivX? to my Showcenter 200 and XBMC perfectly. If only it had a better web interface and was able to mimic the menu presentation of Twonky my search would be at an end.

to:

Latest version of Twonky 5.01 is unable to handle my collection of >20000 songs, it runs out of memory. So I'm now in the process of trying all of the available media servers to find a replacement that is actively supported. Have tried Ushare, FireFly and MediaTomb, Ushare is the only one so far to cope with the number of songs. Ushare has also streamed DivX? to my Showcenter 200 and XBMC perfectly. If only it had a better web interface and was able to mimic the menu presentation of Twonky my search would be at an end.

Restore
October 04, 2010, at 05:41 PM by flowoess --
Changed lines 168-169 from:

Okt 2010: Have tested uShare, MediaTomb and finally Twonky. uShare just let you browse the files - no database, no ID-Tag reading, which is fine, because my 20 000+ files where up in under a minute, but when i browse the files with my AV-Receiver it gives me annoying timeouts every few folders i browse. So i tried MediaTomb - very easy to set up and configure but it took MediaTomb 24h to browse through half of my files - damn slow... I'm now very happy with Twonky, they support the NSLU2 again with verion 6.0.23 (2010) - can be found here: http://www.twonkyforum.com/downloads/6.0.23/. Suprisingly it brings an installer with it, which sets the whole thing up in < 1 minute (seems to work via telnet)! Indexing my 20,000 files was finisthed in 15 min and browsing the files with my AV-Receiver was very fast (flac is supported too). Will Update the Townky HowTo here now...

to:

Okt 2010: Have tested uShare, MediaTomb and finally Twonky. uShare just let you browse the files - no database, no ID-Tag reading, which is fine, because my 20 000+ files where up in under a minute, but when i browse the files with my AV-Receiver it gives me annoying timeouts every few folders i browse. So i tried MediaTomb - very easy to set up and configure but it took MediaTomb 24h to browse through half of my files - damn slow... I'm now very happy with Twonky, they support the NSLU2 again with verion 6.0.23 (2010) - can be found here: http://www.twonkyforum.com/downloads/6.0.23/. Suprisingly it brings an installer with it, which sets the whole thing up in < 1 minute (seems to work via telnet)! Indexing my 20,000 files was finisthed in 15 min and browsing the files with my AV-Receiver was very fast (flac is supported too). Updated the TwonkyVision Page.

Restore
October 04, 2010, at 05:24 PM by flowoess --
Changed line 33 from:

(:cell:)4.4

to:

(:cell:)6.0.23

Restore
October 04, 2010, at 05:23 PM by flowoess -- Updated Twonky Data and made a little comparison
Changed line 26 from:

(:cell:)4.4

to:

(:cell:)6.0.23

Changed line 41 from:

(:cell:)$39.95 USD

to:

(:cell:)$19.95 USD

Changed line 55 from:

(:cell:)mp3, wma, AAC (all)

to:

(:cell:)mp3, wma, flac, AAC (all)

Added lines 168-169:

Okt 2010: Have tested uShare, MediaTomb and finally Twonky. uShare just let you browse the files - no database, no ID-Tag reading, which is fine, because my 20 000+ files where up in under a minute, but when i browse the files with my AV-Receiver it gives me annoying timeouts every few folders i browse. So i tried MediaTomb - very easy to set up and configure but it took MediaTomb 24h to browse through half of my files - damn slow... I'm now very happy with Twonky, they support the NSLU2 again with verion 6.0.23 (2010) - can be found here: http://www.twonkyforum.com/downloads/6.0.23/. Suprisingly it brings an installer with it, which sets the whole thing up in < 1 minute (seems to work via telnet)! Indexing my 20,000 files was finisthed in 15 min and browsing the files with my AV-Receiver was very fast (flac is supported too). Will Update the Townky HowTo here now...

Restore
January 16, 2010, at 12:06 AM by japher -- Added xbox 260 support info and memory footprint for uSharej
Added line 112:

(:cell:)~3MB

Added lines 116-117:

(:cellnr:)approx memory used per song:

Deleted lines 118-119:

(:cellnr:)approx memory used per song:

Changed lines 123-124 from:

(:cell:)unknown

to:
Added line 147:

(:cell:)yes

Added lines 151-152:

(:cellnr:)Supported Players

Deleted lines 153-155:

(:cellnr:)Supported Players (:cell:)unknown

Restore
November 03, 2008, at 05:36 PM by IanP --
Changed lines 186-189 from:

When using uShare with the D-Link Medialounge DSM-510 I receive error message 'Not authorized to browse this server.' However, it works flawlessly when the client is XBMC.

to:

When using uShare with the D-Link Medialounge DSM-510 I receive error message 'Not authorized to browse this server.' However, it works flawlessly when the client is XBMC.

Nov 3rd 2008 Latest version of Twonky 5.01 is unable to handle my collection of >20000 songs, it runs out of memory. So I'm now in the process of trying all of the available media servers to find a replacement that is actively supported. Have tried Ushare, FireFly? and MediaTomb, Ushare is the only one so far to cope with the number of songs. Ushare has also streamed DivX? to my Showcenter 200 and XBMC perfectly. If only it had a better web interface and was able to mimic the menu presentation of Twonky my search would be at an end.

Restore
October 15, 2008, at 08:30 PM by elcano -- Type.
Changed line 186 from:

When using uShare with the D-Link Medialounge DSM-510 I receive error message 'Not authorized to browse this server.' However, it works flawlessly when yhe client is XBMC.

to:

When using uShare with the D-Link Medialounge DSM-510 I receive error message 'Not authorized to browse this server.' However, it works flawlessly when the client is XBMC.

Restore
October 15, 2008, at 08:29 PM by elcano -- uShare problem with D-Link DSM-510
Added lines 185-186:

When using uShare with the D-Link Medialounge DSM-510 I receive error message 'Not authorized to browse this server.' However, it works flawlessly when yhe client is XBMC.

Restore
October 02, 2008, at 05:13 AM by David Rubie -- Added info about linux mtpcenter
Changed lines 182-184 from:

Aug 29th 2008 - Added Xbox360 section - I can confirm Twonky works fine - others need testing.

to:

Aug 29th 2008 - Added Xbox360 section - I can confirm Twonky works fine - others need testing.

I installed linux_mtpcenter_2.0 from a tarball, using lighttpd and mysql. It's sluggish on 6000 songs but works OK as long as you disable the background picture generation. Video playback is fine, has shoutcast radio stations which work fine. It's another option anyway (although I think it's mostly a Syabas solution rather than a UPnP server). I tried running with Apache first, but that was so slow it was unusable (1 october 2008).

Restore
August 29, 2008, at 06:41 AM by pembo --
Changed line 131 from:

(:cellnr:)`iTunes Library Utilisation:

to:

(:cellnr:)iTunes Library Utilisation:

Restore
August 29, 2008, at 06:40 AM by pembo --
Changed line 111 from:

(:cell:)~6MB

to:

(:cell:)~6MB

Added lines 131-137:

(:cellnr:)`iTunes Library Utilisation: (:cell:)yes (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown

Restore
August 29, 2008, at 06:38 AM by pembo --
Changed line 90 from:

(:cell:)Yes (Most Played / Last Played)

to:

(:cell:)Yes (Most Played / Last Played)

Changed line 139 from:

(:cell:)yes

to:

(:cell:)yes

Restore
August 29, 2008, at 06:38 AM by pembo --
Added lines 90-91:

(:cell:)Yes (Most Played / Last Played) (:cell:)unknown

Deleted line 92:

(:cell:)unknown

Deleted line 93:

(:cell:)no

Restore
August 29, 2008, at 06:35 AM by pembo -- Added twonky memory footprint
Added line 111:

(:cell:)~6MB

Added lines 116-117:

(:cellnr:)approx memory used per song:

Deleted lines 118-119:

(:cellnr:)approx memory used per song:

Changed lines 123-124 from:

(:cell:)unknown

to:
Restore
August 29, 2008, at 06:32 AM by pembo -- added xbox360 compat
Changed lines 138-139 from:

(:cellnr:)Supported Players

to:

(:cellnr:)XBox 360 support: (:cell:)yes

Deleted line 140:

(:cell:)Known to work with DSM-520

Added lines 143-149:

(:cell:)unknown

(:cellnr:)Supported Players (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)Known to work with DSM-520 (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown

Changed lines 173-175 from:

Another answer, Aug 21st 2008, I'm using uShare with 17500 songs and around 40 movies and it works like a charm! I'm also running on a Debian slug.

to:

Another answer, Aug 21st 2008, I'm using uShare with 17500 songs and around 40 movies and it works like a charm! I'm also running on a Debian slug.

Aug 29th 2008 - Added Xbox360 section - I can confirm Twonky works fine - others need testing.

Restore
August 21, 2008, at 06:24 AM by Mikael --
Added lines 138-144:

(:cellnr:)Supported Players (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)Known to work with DSM-520 (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)Syabas based players such as: Pinnacle's Showcenters

Restore
August 21, 2008, at 06:21 AM by Mikael --
Added lines 158-159:

Another answer, Aug 21st 2008, I'm using uShare with 17500 songs and around 40 movies and it works like a charm! I'm also running on a Debian slug.

Restore
August 21, 2008, at 06:18 AM by Mikael --
Changed lines 12-16 from:

(:cell width=15%:)TwonkyVision (:cell width=15%:)uShare (:cell width=15%:)Fuppes (:cell width=15%:)MediaTomb

to:

(:cell width=12%:)TwonkyVision (:cell width=12%:)uShare (:cell width=12%:)Fuppes (:cell width=12%:)MediaTomb (:cell width=12%:)Wizd

Changed lines 23-24 from:
to:

(:cell:)No package, see SF

Changed lines 30-31 from:
to:

(:cell:)v24 (07/11/2006)

Changed lines 37-38 from:
to:

(:cell:)v24 (07/11/2006)

Changed lines 45-46 from:
to:

(:cell:)free

Changed lines 52-53 from:
to:

(:cell:)GPL2

Changed lines 59-60 from:
to:

(:cell:)Unknown

Changed lines 66-67 from:
to:

(:cell:)see homepage

Changed lines 73-74 from:
to:

(:cell:)see homepage

Changed lines 80-81 from:
to:

(:cell:)See Homepage

Changed lines 87-88 from:
to:

(:cell:)See Homepage

Changed lines 94-95 from:
to:

(:cell:)Yes (If I understand what on-the-fly playlists is...)

Changed lines 101-102 from:
to:

(:cell:)Don't think so.

Changed lines 108-109 from:
to:

(:cell:)No

Deleted lines 114-115:

(:cellnr:)approx memory used per song:

Added lines 116-117:

(:cellnr:)approx memory used per song:

Deleted lines 120-122:

(:cellnr:)largest database: (:cell:)>18000 Files

Added lines 123-127:

(:cellnr:)largest database: (:cell:)>18000 Files (:cell:)unknown - I have 17500 songs at the moment, works like a charm (:cell:)unknown

Changed lines 129-130 from:
to:

(:cell:)unknown

Changed lines 136-137 from:
to:

(:cell:)unknown

Restore
May 12, 2008, at 05:41 PM by David Hicks -- Answer to question
Changed lines 137-139 from:

Question - Feb 19th 2008 - Have you tried fuppes? I'm not going to pay for twonky and mediatomb was looking like the best option until your post above. Any idea how fuppes/uShare compare?

to:

Question - Feb 19th 2008 - Have you tried fuppes? I'm not going to pay for twonky and mediatomb was looking like the best option until your post above. Any idea how fuppes/uShare compare?

Bit of an answer from someone who didn't write this page - May 12th 08 - I'm using uShare at home. Memory usage is fine and my (Debian) slug can stream video to the xbox just fine. However I did try and set it loose on my music directory and it choked after 1000 songs

Restore
March 10, 2008, at 09:06 AM by Jin --
Changed lines 27-28 from:

(:cell:)0.10.0

to:

(:cell:)0.11.0

Changed lines 33-35 from:

(:cell:)0.10.0

to:

(:cell:)0.11.0

Changed lines 58-59 from:

(:cell:)none

to:

(:cell:)see mediatomb homepage

Restore
February 19, 2008, at 12:58 PM by David Hicks -- Question to the author
Changed lines 135-137 from:

Note: Dec 21/2007. I tried MediaTomb 0.10 on the slug. It works...But. I have a music collection of 13000 songs. It took 24 hours to get through 3500 songs. I killed it at that point. Twonky took about 5 minutes. But now Twonky is NOT supporting NAS devices moving forward. So. Still searching for a good UPNP server.....

to:

Note: Dec 21/2007. I tried MediaTomb 0.10 on the slug. It works...But. I have a music collection of 13000 songs. It took 24 hours to get through 3500 songs. I killed it at that point. Twonky took about 5 minutes. But now Twonky is NOT supporting NAS devices moving forward. So. Still searching for a good UPNP server.....

Question - Feb 19th 2008 - Have you tried fuppes? I'm not going to pay for twonky and mediatomb was looking like the best option until your post above. Any idea how fuppes/uShare compare?

Restore
February 17, 2008, at 04:51 PM by eddie -- ushare updates
Changed line 25 from:

(:cell:)0.9.10

to:

(:cell:)1.1a

Changed line 31 from:

(:cell:)unknown

to:

(:cell:)1.1a

Changed line 50 from:

(:cell:)mp3

to:

(:cell:)see ushare homepage

Changed line 56 from:

(:cell:)unknown

to:

(:cell:)no transcoding

Changed line 62 from:

(:cell:)mpeg4, etc

to:

(:cell:)see ushare homepage

Changed line 68 from:

(:cell:)unknown

to:

(:cell:)see ushare homepage

Changed line 92 from:

(:cell:)unknown

to:

(:cell:)no

Added lines 129-130:

Feb 2008: Updated ushare data, removed note about invalid characters and ushare, as ushare now supports configurable behaviour regarding invalid characters in filenames.

Deleted lines 132-133:

Note: The last time that I tried (about May 07), uShare would suppress albums, artists or songs having accented characters. While some systems replace only the unknown character with a box, uShare is filtering the whole content affected. Since I dont really need uPnP because my media player is XBMC, I switched to xbmsp which handles my MP3 lists without problems (and very fast). - elcano

Restore
January 08, 2008, at 12:01 PM by fcarolo -- fixed false wikilink
Changed line 135 from:

Note: Dec 21/2007. I tried MediaTomb 0.10 on the slug. It works...But. I have a music collection of 13000 songs. It took 24 hours to get through 3500 songs. I killed it at that point. Twonky took about 5 minutes. But now Twonky is NOT supporting NAS devices moving forward. So. Still searching for a good UPNP server.....

to:

Note: Dec 21/2007. I tried MediaTomb 0.10 on the slug. It works...But. I have a music collection of 13000 songs. It took 24 hours to get through 3500 songs. I killed it at that point. Twonky took about 5 minutes. But now Twonky is NOT supporting NAS devices moving forward. So. Still searching for a good UPNP server.....

Restore
December 22, 2007, at 12:25 AM by Gerry -- Note:
Changed lines 133-135 from:

As of 2007-09-23, Mediatomb can support transcoding via plugins... this means that it should be able to transcode anything provided you can find the plugin for it. This functionality is still beta, but very promising.

to:

As of 2007-09-23, Mediatomb can support transcoding via plugins... this means that it should be able to transcode anything provided you can find the plugin for it. This functionality is still beta, but very promising.

Note: Dec 21/2007. I tried MediaTomb 0.10 on the slug. It works...But. I have a music collection of 13000 songs. It took 24 hours to get through 3500 songs. I killed it at that point. Twonky took about 5 minutes. But now Twonky is NOT supporting NAS devices moving forward. So. Still searching for a good UPNP server.....

Restore
September 23, 2007, at 10:23 PM by BrianZhou -- updated most recent version of mediatomb
Changed lines 33-35 from:

(:cell:)0.9.1

to:

(:cell:)0.10.0

Restore
September 23, 2007, at 07:41 PM by PeterW --
Changed lines 131-133 from:

Note: The last time that I tried (about May 07), uShare would suppress albums, artists or songs having accented characters. While some systems replace only the unknown character with a box, uShare is filtering the whole content affected. Since I dont really need uPnP because my media player is XBMC, I switched to xbmsp which handles my MP3 lists without problems (and very fast). - elcano

to:

Note: The last time that I tried (about May 07), uShare would suppress albums, artists or songs having accented characters. While some systems replace only the unknown character with a box, uShare is filtering the whole content affected. Since I dont really need uPnP because my media player is XBMC, I switched to xbmsp which handles my MP3 lists without problems (and very fast). - elcano

As of 2007-09-23, Mediatomb can support transcoding via plugins... this means that it should be able to transcode anything provided you can find the plugin for it. This functionality is still beta, but very promising.

Restore
September 14, 2007, at 08:13 PM by fcarolo -- fixed false wikilink
Changed line 114 from:

(:cellnr:)PS3? support:

to:

(:cellnr:)PS3 support:

Restore
September 14, 2007, at 08:13 PM by fcarolo -- fixed false wikilink
Changed line 131 from:

Note: The last time that I tried (about May 07), uShare would suppress albums, artists or songs having accented characters. While some systems replace only the unknown character with a box, uShare is filtering the whole content affected. Since I dont really need uPnP because my media player is XBMC, I switched to xbmsp which handles my MP3? lists without problems (and very fast). - elcano

to:

Note: The last time that I tried (about May 07), uShare would suppress albums, artists or songs having accented characters. While some systems replace only the unknown character with a box, uShare is filtering the whole content affected. Since I dont really need uPnP because my media player is XBMC, I switched to xbmsp which handles my MP3 lists without problems (and very fast). - elcano

Restore
September 14, 2007, at 05:05 PM by voelkel -- fuppes
Changed line 14 from:

(:cell width=15%:)Fuppes

to:

(:cell width=15%:)Fuppes

Changed line 26 from:

(:cell:)0.7.1

to:

(:cell:)SVN-524

Deleted line 50:

(:cell:)mp3, ogg, flac, mpc

Changed lines 52-53 from:
to:

(:cell:)all

Changed line 57 from:

(:cell:)ogg, flac & mpc to mp3 or mpeg2

to:

(:cell:)ogg, flac, mpc & aac/mp4 to mp3, mpeg2, pcm or wav

Deleted line 62:

(:cell:)unknown

Changed lines 64-65 from:
to:

(:cell:)all

Deleted line 68:

(:cell:)unknown

Changed lines 70-71 from:
to:

(:cell:)all

Deleted line 80:

(:cell:)unknown

Changed lines 82-83 from:
to:

(:cell:)no

Added line 87:

(:cell:)no

Added lines 89-91:

(:cellnr:)persistant database: (:cell:)yes

Deleted lines 92-93:

(:cellnr:)persistant database:

Deleted line 93:

(:cell:)unknown

Changed lines 95-96 from:

(:cell:)yes

to:
Deleted line 116:

(:cell:)unknown

Changed lines 118-119 from:
to:

(:cell:)yes

Restore
July 13, 2007, at 04:01 PM by ptrapnes --
Added line 62:

(:cell:)mpeg4, etc

Deleted line 63:

(:cell:)unknown

Changed line 114 from:

(:cellnr:)PS3? suport:

to:

(:cellnr:)PS3? support:

Restore
July 13, 2007, at 03:58 PM by ptrapnes --
Changed lines 76-77 from:

(:cell:)none

to:

(:cell:)pls, m3u, other

Changed lines 112-113 from:

(:cell:)limited by device storage

to:

(:cell:)limited by device storage

(:cellnr:)PS3? suport: (:cell:)yes (:cell:)video (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)yes

Restore
July 13, 2007, at 03:52 PM by ptrapnes --
Changed lines 27-28 from:

(:cell:)0.9.1

to:

(:cell:)0.10.0

Restore
July 06, 2007, at 05:03 AM by elcano -- fixed typos on my prior posting.
Changed line 125 from:

Note: The las time that I tried (about May 07), uShare would suppress albums, artists or songs having accented characters. While some systems replace only the unknown character with a box, uShare is filtering the whole content affected. Since I dont rreally need uPnP because my media player is XBMC, I switched to xbmsp which handles my MP3? lists without problems (and very fast). - elcano

to:

Note: The last time that I tried (about May 07), uShare would suppress albums, artists or songs having accented characters. While some systems replace only the unknown character with a box, uShare is filtering the whole content affected. Since I dont really need uPnP because my media player is XBMC, I switched to xbmsp which handles my MP3? lists without problems (and very fast). - elcano

Restore
July 06, 2007, at 05:01 AM by elcano -- uShare suppress entries with accented characters
Changed lines 123-125 from:

The goal behind this page is to make a comprehensive comparison of the uPnP solutions out there specifically with the NSLU2 in mind. Ultimately, I hope to fill in all the unknown values above and add more.

to:

The goal behind this page is to make a comprehensive comparison of the uPnP solutions out there specifically with the NSLU2 in mind. Ultimately, I hope to fill in all the unknown values above and add more.

Note: The las time that I tried (about May 07), uShare would suppress albums, artists or songs having accented characters. While some systems replace only the unknown character with a box, uShare is filtering the whole content affected. Since I dont rreally need uPnP because my media player is XBMC, I switched to xbmsp which handles my MP3? lists without problems (and very fast). - elcano

Restore
June 23, 2007, at 03:37 PM by Michael -- Update
Changed line 24 from:

(:cell:)4.2

to:

(:cell:)4.4

Changed line 30 from:

(:cell:)4.2

to:

(:cell:)4.4

Restore
June 11, 2007, at 05:44 PM by fcarolo -- removed false wikilinks
Deleted line 44:

(:cell:)GPL2?

Changed lines 46-47 from:
to:

(:cell:)GPL2

Restore
June 08, 2007, at 09:33 AM by fuppes --
Changed line 45 from:

(:cell:)GPL

to:

(:cell:)GPL2?

Changed line 51 from:

(:cell:)mp3

to:

(:cell:)mp3, ogg, flac, mpc

Changed line 57 from:

(:cell:)unknown

to:

(:cell:)ogg, flac & mpc to mp3 or mpeg2

Changed line 75 from:

(:cell:)unknown

to:

(:cell:)pls, m3u

Deleted line 92:

(:cell:)unknown

Changed lines 94-95 from:
to:

(:cell:)yes

Restore
June 06, 2007, at 10:55 PM by Jin -- upping MediaTomb version
Changed lines 27-28 from:

(:cell:)0.9.0

to:

(:cell:)0.9.1

Changed lines 33-35 from:

(:cell:)0.9.0

to:

(:cell:)0.9.1

Restore
May 04, 2007, at 01:47 PM by Psychodad -- more twonky infos
Added line 49:

(:cell:)mp3, wma, AAC (all)

Deleted line 51:

(:cell:)mp3

Added line 73:

(:cell:)pls, m3u

Deleted line 75:

(:cell:)unknown

Changed line 91 from:

(:cell:)no

to:

(:cell:)yes

Restore
May 02, 2007, at 11:35 AM by infoball -- Added some Twonkyvision info (not exhaustive)
Changed line 24 from:

(:cell:)4.1

to:

(:cell:)4.2

Changed line 30 from:

(:cell:)4.1

to:

(:cell:)4.2

Added line 61:

(:cell:)mpeg1, mpeg2, mpeg4, etc

Deleted line 63:

(:cell:)unknown

Added line 67:

(:cell:)jpeg, etc

Deleted line 69:

(:cell:)unknown

Restore
May 01, 2007, at 02:36 AM by fcarolo -- fixed false wikiwords
Changed line 44 from:

(:cell:)GPL2?

to:

(:cell:)GPL2

Changed lines 46-47 from:

(:cell:)GPL2?

to:

(:cell:)GPL2

Restore
April 30, 2007, at 08:42 PM by Jin -- updated most recent MediaTomb version number
Changed lines 27-28 from:

(:cell:)0.9.0-pre

to:

(:cell:)0.9.0

Changed lines 33-35 from:

(:cell:)0.9.0-pre

to:

(:cell:)0.9.0

Restore
March 24, 2007, at 06:39 PM by Jin -- fixed the MediaTomb link
Changed lines 21-22 from:

(:cell:)see MediaTomb?

to:

(:cell:)see MediaTomb

Restore
March 20, 2007, at 05:39 PM by Jin -- filled in information regarding MediaTomb
Changed lines 27-28 from:

(:cell:)0.9.0

to:

(:cell:)0.9.0-pre

Changed lines 33-35 from:

(:cell:)0.9.0

to:

(:cell:)0.9.0-pre

Changed lines 46-47 from:

(:cell:)GPL

to:

(:cell:)GPL2?

Changed lines 52-53 from:

(:cell:)mp3

to:

(:cell:)all

Added lines 58-60:

(:cell:)none

(:cellnr:)Video formats:

Deleted lines 61-62:

(:cellnr:)Video formats:

Added lines 64-66:

(:cell:)all

(:cellnr:)Image formats:

Deleted lines 68-69:

(:cellnr:)Image formats:

Added lines 70-72:

(:cell:)all

(:cellnr:)Playlist formats:

Changed lines 76-77 from:

(:cellnr:)Playlist formats:

to:

(:cell:)none

(:cellnr:)on-the-fly playlists: (:cell:)no

Added lines 82-85:

(:cell:)no

(:cellnr:)Internet radio: (:cell:)Shoutcast

Deleted lines 87-89:

(:cellnr:)on-the-fly playlists: (:cell:)no

Added lines 89-91:

(:cellnr:)persistant database: (:cell:)no

Changed lines 94-96 from:

(:cellnr:)Internet radio: (:cell:)Shoutcast

to:

(:cell:)yes

(:cellnr:)base application memory footprint:

Deleted lines 99-101:

(:cellnr:)persistant database: (:cell:)no

Added lines 101-102:

(:cellnr:)approx memory used per song:

Deleted lines 104-105:

(:cellnr:)base application memory footprint:

Added lines 107-109:

(:cellnr:)largest database: (:cell:)>18000 Files

Changed lines 112-124 from:

(:cellnr:)approx memory used per song: (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown

(:cellnr:)largest database: (:cell:)>18000 Files (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown

to:

(:cell:)limited by device storage

Restore
March 18, 2007, at 09:50 PM by IanP -- Twonky update
Added line 85:

(:cell:)Shoutcast

Added lines 89-91:

(:cellnr:)persistant database: (:cell:)no

Deleted lines 92-94:

(:cellnr:)persistant database: (:cell:)no

Added lines 95-96:

(:cellnr:)base application memory footprint:

Deleted lines 97-98:

(:cellnr:)base application memory footprint:

Added lines 101-102:

(:cellnr:)approx memory used per song:

Deleted lines 103-104:

(:cellnr:)approx memory used per song:

Added lines 107-109:

(:cellnr:)largest database: (:cell:)>18000 Files

Deleted lines 110-112:

(:cellnr:)largest database: (:cell:)>15000 Files

Changed lines 113-114 from:

(:cell:)unknown

to:
Restore
March 09, 2007, at 04:09 AM by the_orn --
Changed lines 48-54 from:

(:cellnr:)Media Formats missing:

to:

(:cellnr:)Audio formats (native): (:cell:)mp3 (:cell:)mp3 (:cell:)mp3 (:cell:)mp3

(:cellnr:)Audio formats (transcoded):

Changed lines 60-61 from:

(:cellnr:)on-the-fly playlists: (:cell:)no

to:

(:cellnr:)Video formats:

Deleted lines 63-65:

(:cellnr:)persistant database: (:cell:)no

Added lines 65-66:

(:cellnr:)Image formats:

Deleted lines 68-69:

(:cellnr:)base application memory footprint:

Added lines 71-72:

(:cellnr:)Playlist formats:

Deleted lines 74-75:

(:cellnr:)approx memory used per song:

Added lines 77-79:

(:cellnr:)on-the-fly playlists: (:cell:)no

Deleted lines 81-83:

(:cellnr:)largest database: (:cell:)>15000 Files

Added lines 83-84:

(:cellnr:)Internet radio:

Changed lines 87-113 from:
to:

(:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown

(:cellnr:)persistant database: (:cell:)no (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown

(:cellnr:)base application memory footprint: (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown

(:cellnr:)approx memory used per song: (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown

(:cellnr:)largest database: (:cell:)>15000 Files (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown

Restore
March 08, 2007, at 08:43 AM by Psychodad -- added Database Size for Twonky
Added line 79:

(:cell:)>15000 Files

Changed lines 83-84 from:

(:cell:)unknown

to:
Restore
March 07, 2007, at 10:15 PM by the_orn --
Changed lines 18-19 from:

(:cell:)see TwonkyVision (to be written) (:cell:)see uShare (to be written)

to:

(:cell:)see TwonkyVision (:cell:)see uShare

Changed lines 21-22 from:

(:cell:)see MediaTomb (to be written)

to:

(:cell:)see MediaTomb?

Restore
March 07, 2007, at 10:13 PM by the_orn --
Changed line 18 from:

(:cell:)see TwonkyVision (to be written)

to:

(:cell:)see TwonkyVision (to be written)

Restore
March 07, 2007, at 10:10 PM by the_orn --
Changed line 18 from:

(:cell:)see TwonkyVision (to be written)

to:

(:cell:)see TwonkyVision (to be written)

Restore
March 07, 2007, at 09:51 PM by fcarolo -- Fixed and approved links
Changed lines 15-16 from:

(:cell width=15%:)MediaTomb

to:

(:cell width=15%:)MediaTomb

Changed lines 18-19 from:

(:cell:)see TwonkyVision (:cell:)see uShare?

to:

(:cell:)see TwonkyVision (to be written) (:cell:)see uShare (to be written)

Changed lines 21-22 from:

(:cell:)see MediaTomb

to:

(:cell:)see MediaTomb (to be written)

Changed lines 93-95 from:

The goal behind this page is to make a comprehensive comparison of the uPnP solutions out there specifically with the NSLU2 in mind. Ultimately, I hope to fill in all the unknown values above and add more.

I'd like to add the MediaTomb website (mediatomb.cc) but the wiki won't let me save the page if that address is on the page. Also, I'd like to get the external site links approved.

to:

The goal behind this page is to make a comprehensive comparison of the uPnP solutions out there specifically with the NSLU2 in mind. Ultimately, I hope to fill in all the unknown values above and add more.

Restore
March 07, 2007, at 09:27 PM by the_orn --
Deleted lines 37-38:

(:cell:)see uShare? (:cell:)see InstallFuppesUPNPMediaServer

Changed lines 39-41 from:
to:

(:cell:)free (:cell:)free

Changed lines 48-49 from:

(:cellnr:)on-the-fly playlists: (:cell:)no

to:

(:cellnr:)Media Formats missing:

Deleted lines 51-53:

(:cellnr:)persistant database: (:cell:)no

Added lines 53-55:

(:cellnr:)on-the-fly playlists: (:cell:)no

Deleted lines 57-58:

(:cellnr:)base application memory footprint:

Added lines 59-61:

(:cellnr:)persistant database: (:cell:)no

Changed line 66 from:

(:cellnr:)approx memory used per song:

to:

(:cellnr:)base application memory footprint:

Changed line 72 from:

(:cellnr:)largest database:

to:

(:cellnr:)approx memory used per song:

Added lines 78-83:

(:cellnr:)largest database: (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown

Restore
March 07, 2007, at 09:05 PM by the_orn --
Deleted line 0:

<<<<<<<

Added lines 72-77:

(:cellnr:)largest database: (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown

Deleted lines 89-92:

======= Compare uPnP Media Servers >>>>>>>

Restore
March 07, 2007, at 09:03 PM by the_orn --
Changed lines 12-17 from:

(:cell:)feature (:cell:)TwonkyVision (:cell:)uShare (:cell:)Fuppes (:cell:)MediaTomb

to:

(:cell width=40%:)feature (:cell width=15%:)TwonkyVision (:cell width=15%:)uShare (:cell width=15%:)Fuppes (:cell width=15%:)MediaTomb

Restore
March 07, 2007, at 09:01 PM by the_orn --
Added lines 24-36:

(:cellnr:)most recent version: (:cell:)4.1 (:cell:)0.9.10 (:cell:)0.7.1 (:cell:)0.9.0

(:cellnr:)most recent version for NSLU2: (:cell:)4.1 (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)0.7.1 (:cell:)0.9.0

Added lines 49-72:

(:cellnr:)on-the-fly playlists: (:cell:)no (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown

(:cellnr:)persistant database: (:cell:)no (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown

(:cellnr:)base application memory footprint: (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown

(:cellnr:)approx memory used per song: (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown (:cell:)unknown

Added lines 79-85:

Edit Notes

The goal behind this page is to make a comprehensive comparison of the uPnP solutions out there specifically with the NSLU2 in mind. Ultimately, I hope to fill in all the unknown values above and add more.

I'd like to add the MediaTomb website (mediatomb.cc) but the wiki won't let me save the page if that address is on the page. Also, I'd like to get the external site links approved.

Restore
March 07, 2007, at 08:42 PM by the_orn --
Changed lines 10-11 from:

(:table border=1 cellpadding=5 cellspacing=0:)

to:

(:table border=1 cellpadding=1 cellspacing=1:)

Restore
March 07, 2007, at 08:41 PM by the_orn --
Restore
March 07, 2007, at 08:40 PM by the_orn --
Changed lines 14-17 from:

(:cell:)http://ushare.geexbox.org - uShare (:cell:)http://fuppes.sourceforge.net/index.php/Main_Page - Fuppes (:cell:) MediaTomb

to:

(:cell:)uShare (:cell:)Fuppes (:cell:)MediaTomb

Restore
March 07, 2007, at 08:38 PM by the_orn --
Changed lines 16-35 from:
to:

(:cell:) MediaTomb

(:cellnr:)Installation: (:cell:)see TwonkyVision (:cell:)see uShare? (:cell:)see InstallFuppesUPNPMediaServer (:cell:)see MediaTomb

(:cellnr:)Cost (in USD): (:cell:)$39.95 USD (:cell:)see uShare? (:cell:)see InstallFuppesUPNPMediaServer (:cell:)free

(:cellnr:)License: (:cell:)commercial (:cell:)GPL2? (:cell:)GPL (:cell:)GPL

Restore
March 07, 2007, at 08:37 PM by the_orn --
Added lines 15-19:

(:cell:)http://fuppes.sourceforge.net/index.php/Main_Page - Fuppes

(:tableend:)

Restore
March 07, 2007, at 08:36 PM by the_orn --
Changed lines 14-16 from:

(:tableend:)

to:

(:cell:)http://ushare.geexbox.org - uShare

Restore
March 07, 2007, at 08:36 PM by the_orn --
Changed lines 13-14 from:

(:cell:)http://www.twonkymedia.com - TwonkyVision

to:

(:cell:)TwonkyVision

Restore
March 07, 2007, at 08:35 PM by the_orn --
Changed lines 13-14 from:
to:

(:cell:)http://www.twonkymedia.com - TwonkyVision

Restore
March 07, 2007, at 08:35 PM by the_orn --
Changed lines 12-13 from:
to:

(:cell:)feature

Restore
March 07, 2007, at 08:34 PM by the_orn --
Changed lines 10-14 from:
to:

(:table border=1 cellpadding=5 cellspacing=0:)

(:tableend:)

Restore
March 07, 2007, at 08:32 PM by the_orn -- initial comparison table
Changed lines 1-16 from:

Compare uPnP Media Servers

to:

<<<<<<<

About

There are many uPnP media servers that can be run on the NSLU2. This page compares them.

The Table

The following table compares the known uPnP media servers available for the NSLU2. No particular preference is implied.

External Links

http://www.upnp.org - uPnP Forum ======= Compare uPnP Media Servers >>>>>>>

Restore
March 07, 2007, at 08:30 PM by the_orn --
Added line 1:

Compare uPnP Media Servers

Restore
view · edit · print · history · Last edited by OddballHero.
Based on work by flowoess, japher, IanP, elcano, David Rubie, pembo, Mikael, David Hicks, Jin, eddie, fcarolo, Gerry, BrianZhou, PeterW, voelkel, ptrapnes, Michael, fuppes, Psychodad, infoball, and the_orn.
Originally by the_orn.
Page last modified on March 10, 2011, at 10:47 AM